• 0 Posts
  • 28 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 10th, 2023

help-circle
rss

  • Once this has been implemented, something worse can be implemented.

    I don’t like these slippery slope arguments. You might as well reduce it to any legislation.
    Once people are allowed to make laws, bad people can make bad laws.
    Which is why we must continue to vote in the right people, not abandon the concept of laws.

    In this case, I don’t doubt that copyright infringement and general censorship are on some people’s agenda.
    But this current proposal is bad enough itself and should be opposed because of that and not because someone might make other, even worse proposals in the future.






  • there is a difference between the end of a LICENCE and the end of something’s functional life?

    This may be somewhat pedantic but the plant’s functional life ended when the license ran out.
    The planned/ hoped for EoL may have been longer but if there was a 40 year license then the end of that license is also the end of the initially licensed lifetime. Otherwise they could have just issued a 50 or 60 year license.
    That doesn’t mean lifetimes cannot be extended, many plants run longer than initially planned.
    But not renewing a license is hardly a premature shutdown,

    But NONE of that means that the plant was some falling apart scrapheap that needed closed

    As already stated, I didn’t make any argument about its functionality and it has no bearing to my argument.
    That said, other have claimed that the plant was apparently leaking, which does sound like an argument against renewal.


  • I never claimed that the license couldn’t be renewed nor that it wouldn’t be running fine.
    The license period had a pre-determined END and it’s LIFEtime has not been extended.
    Surely the very existence of a time limit to the license must mean that the option to not renew it after a certain time has been anticipated when the license was originally issued.

    And for all that it does not matter, whether that was the correct decision or not, whether other plants had their licenses renewed orwhether these other plants are operating just fine.